DriversRecommendedOutdated drivers can make a good PC feel brokenScan driver issues before chasing fixes manually.Scan NowOctober DealsAmazon USOctober deal check: compare before you payAmazon US: current deals, useful picks and tech finds.Check DealsPC HealthRecommendedCrashes, freezes, slowdowns? Check your PC nowSpot repairable issues before they interrupt work.Check PC×
Skip to content
CarCodyAdvertise
Service recordThe Garage

Did Elon Musk Threaten to Deport a Tesla Engineer’s Team Over a Brake Concern? What Cristina Balan Alleged—and What the Court Decided

Cristina Balan said she raised a concern about Model S floor mats near the brake pedal and alleged a Tesla lawyer threatened her team. The Ninth Circuit later ruled on jurisdiction, not on whether that allegation or a safety defect was real.
Entry074 Date Time2 min MechanicCarCody Team
Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Former Tesla engineer Cristina Balan alleged that a Tesla lawyer threatened to have members of her team deported after she raised a concern about Model S floor mats near the brake pedal. The published reports do not independently verify her account, and the Ninth Circuit’s 2025 ruling did not decide whether the alleged threat or a brake-related defect occurred.

What did Cristina Balan say happened?

In an April 20, 2025 report, Electrek described Balan as a former Tesla engineer and reported that she said she raised a concern in 2014 about Model S floor mats curling near the brake pedal and potentially interfering with braking.

Balan said she tried to bring the issue to Elon Musk after he had invited Tesla employees in a 2013 company-wide email to contact anyone at the company to solve problems. Electrek reproduces the email as saying: “Anyone at Tesla can and should email/talk to anyone else according to what they think is the fastest way to solve a problem for the benefit of the whole company.” It also reproduces the next sentence: “Moreover, you should consider yourself obligated to do so until the right thing happens.” These are the words as quoted by Electrek; the original email was not separately examined for this account.

Balan alleged that, in a meeting after she sought to raise the concern with Musk, a Tesla lawyer threatened that members of her team whose green-card applications were pending would be deported unless she resigned. The report attributes the alleged threat to the lawyer—not to Musk personally. Balan’s reported description of Musk as “pure evil” is her opinion, not a court finding.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.
#1 Best Overall
SCITOO Ceramic Front Rear Disc Brake Pad Set Fit For Toyota For Camry 07-17
  • COMPATIBLE VEHICLES - ATD1222C,D1222-8331 308.12120,EHT1212H,D1212-8332 Ceramic disc brake pad kit for 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 for Lexus ES300h, 2007-2018 for Lexus ES350, 2008-2018 for Toyota Avalon, 2007-2017 for Toyota Camry
  • LONGER SERVICE LIFE - Each brake pad also is treated with the scorch friction process to help lower break-in time, and ensure a more consistent characteristic in the lifespan of the brake pad
  • ULTRA-QUIET - The gasket serves as a buffer between the caliper piston and the brake pad back plate. They act to absorb vibrations, which will reduce noise
  • DIRECT INSTALLATION - Direct factory replacement without alterations or modifications,ready to be installed right out of the box
  • BUYER NOTICE - The product package contains 8pcs brake pads. Please make sure your vehicle matches them before buying.

Was the allegation independently confirmed?

No independent confirmation is established by the cited coverage. InsideEVs reported on April 21, 2025, that it had not independently confirmed Balan’s account and had not spoken with her; it said it had reached out to Tesla. The allegation should therefore be understood as Balan’s account, not as an established finding.

What did the Ninth Circuit decide?

On April 14, 2025, the Ninth Circuit issued its opinion in Tesla Motors, Inc. v. Balan, No. 22-16623. The court vacated a district court order confirming a zero-dollar arbitration award in favor of Tesla and Musk, concluding that the district court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction to confirm the award under the Federal Arbitration Act. It remanded with instructions to dismiss that confirmation action.

Rank #2
SCITOO Front Rear Disc Brake Pad Set w/Hardware For Ford For Transit-150
  • COMPATIBLE VEHICLES : 8PCS Brake Pads For Ford For Transit 2015,For Ford For Transit-150 2015-2021,For Ford For Transit-250 2015-2020,For Ford For Transit-350 2015-2019,For Ford For Transit-350 HD 2015-2022
  • Product Specifications : 8PCS Brake Pads Kits [Front & Rear, Driver and Passenger Side]; FMSI: D1774-9004, D1775-9005; ①Pads Length (Inch): Front - 6.76" & Rear - 5.39"; ②Pads Width (Inch): Front - 2.61" and Rear - Inner Pads - 2.29" & Outer Pads - 2.19"; ③Pads Thickness (Inch): Front - 0.63" & Rear - 0.68"
  • Used For : The gasket serves as a buffer between the caliper piston and the brake pad back plate. They act to absorb vibrations,which will reduce noise
  • Brake Pads Feature : The pads with slotting design increases friction, heated evenly, heat faster,better ventilation, improves drainage.Ensure exceptional stopping power and quiet operation
  • Easy Installation : Manufactured to precise OE requirements to meet your car's needs.Designed to be integrated, easy to install and save time

That was a ruling about the court’s jurisdiction over the confirmation action. It did not decide whether Balan’s account of the lawyer’s alleged threat was true or whether the floor mats presented a safety defect. The appellate court did not find that Tesla threatened deportation, and its decision should not be described as Balan winning the underlying dispute.

Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Support on Ko-Fi

How does the arbitration ruling fit in?

The Ninth Circuit’s opinion recounts that an arbitrator had dismissed Balan’s defamation claims against Tesla and Musk under California’s one-year statute of limitations and issued an award in their favor. That limitations ruling and the appellate decision address different questions: the arbitrator’s ruling concerned whether the defamation claims were timely, while the Ninth Circuit considered whether the district court had jurisdiction to confirm the resulting award. The appellate court vacated the confirmation order; it did not decide the truth of the underlying allegations.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.
Rank #3
SCITOO Ceramic Brake Pads Kits,8pcs Brakes Pads Set For Ford Fusion 2006-12
  • COMPATIBLE VEHICLES : 2006-2012 for Ford for Fusion,2007-2012 for Lincoln for MKZ,2006 for Lincoln for Zephyr,2006-2013 for Mazda for 6,2006-2011 for Mercury for Milan Ceramic Disc Brake Pad Kit for ATD1164C,D1164-8277 ATD1161C,D1161-8272
  • LONGER SERVICE LIFE : Each brake pad also is treated with the scorch friction process to help lower break-in time, and ensure a more consistent characteristic in the lifespan of the brake pad
  • ULTRA-QUIET : The gasket serves as a buffer between the caliper piston and the brake pad back plate. They act to absorb vibrations, which will reduce noise
  • DIRECT INSTALLATION : Direct factory replacement without alterations or modifications,ready to be installed right out of the box
  • BUYER NOTICE : The product package contains 8pcs brake pads. Please make sure your vehicle matches them before buying

Read the Ninth Circuit’s April 14, 2025 opinion for the court’s account of the procedural history and its jurisdictional reasoning.

Best Value
SCITOO Ceramic Front Rear Disc Brake Pad Set For TOYOTA Highlander 2014-19
  • COMPATIBLE VEHICLES - ATD1324C,D1324-8436 D1391-8500 Ceramic disc brake pad kit for 2010-2015 Lexus RX350, 2010-2015 Lexus RX450h, 2014-2019 Toyota Highlander, 2011-2019 Toyota Sienna
  • LONGER SERVICE LIFE - Each brake pad also is treated with the scorch friction process to help lower break-in time, and ensure a more consistent characteristic in the lifespan of the brake pad
  • ULTRA-QUIET - The gasket serves as a buffer between the caliper piston and the brake pad back plate. They act to absorb vibrations, which will reduce noise
  • DIRECT INSTALLATION - Direct factory replacement without alterations or modifications,ready to be installed right out of the box
  • BUYER NOTICE - The product package contains 8pcs brake pads. Please make sure your vehicle matches them before buying.
Rank #4
SCITOO D1509 D1510 Ceramic Brake Pads Sets For INFINITI For QX80 2014-2022
  • 【Applicable Car Models】: 8PCS Brake Pads Kits - (Front and Rear, Driver and Passenger Side) - Compatible For INFINITI For QX56 5.6L 2011 2012 2013,For INFINITI For QX80 5.6L 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022,For Nissan For Armada 5.6L 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
  • 【OE & Certificate】: OE - D1510-8719, D1509-8403; Manufactured in AMECA, NSF, ECE R90, GB5763 certified facilities gives the fit, performance reliability and durability of OE
  • 【Increased Brake Power】: Slots, chamfers and shims to reduce vibration noise and enhance brake bite, provide smooth and quiet braking
  • 【Low Dust Brake Pads】: Ceramic and Organic formulas pads are designed to increase stopping power and keep the wheels clean without damaging the rotors
  • 【Package Details】: 8 x Front Rear Disc Brake Pads Kits. Fits a Specific Model, Please Check Fitment Chart and Product Description for Accurate Information

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.

More from the Garage

  1. Entry001Date09 OCT 26Time3 minWhich Brake Pad Should You Buy From RockAuto or Elsewhere?Section: Blog
  2. Entry002Date09 OCT 26Time5 minThe Pros and Cons of Touchless Car Wash SystemsSection: Blog
  3. Entry003Date09 OCT 26Time3 minCan a Trickle Charger or Battery Tender Properly Charge a Car Battery?Section: Blog

Thanks for visiting Carcody

Carcody.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.co

Recommended PC Tool
Recommended PC Tool
Windows Errors? Fix Them Before They SpreadFree repair scan
Crashes, No Sound, or Screen Glitches?Free driver scan

Two free Windows tools

One Free Minute Could Fix That PC

Before you go - each of these free tools takes about a minute and tackles what quietly slows a Windows PC down.

Special offer. View Outbyte info, uninstall instructions, EULA, and Privacy Policy.