No evidence cited here establishes that BYD is a scam, let alone the biggest one in automotive history. BYD reported substantial 2024 revenue and profit, and Xinhua reported strong vehicle sales. Those figures are not proof that every transaction was sound; equally, allegations repeated by a secondary article are not proof of fraud. The headline is a claim to test, not a verdict supported by the evidence available.
What the headline is alleging
The phrase “biggest scam in automotive history” implies deliberate deception on an extraordinary scale. The MoneyRadar video published July 18, 2025, used that framing and its description raised claims about hidden debt, sales inflation, recalls, and labor issues. A claim that serious requires evidence from underlying financial records, regulators, or documented investigations—not just a provocative title or a list of accusations.
What BYD reported for 2024
BYD’s investor-relations page reports 2024 revenue of RMB 777.102 billion and net profit attributable to shareholders of RMB 40.254 billion. These are company-reported financial results; the figures alone do not establish that the company committed misconduct or that it did not.
| Measure | Reported figure | What the cited source establishes |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | RMB 777.102 billion in 2024 | BYD’s investor-relations page reports this company result. |
| Net profit attributable to shareholders | RMB 40.254 billion in 2024 | BYD’s investor-relations page reports this company result. |
| New energy vehicle sales | 4.272 million in 2024, up 41% year over year | Xinhua, in reporting hosted by Shenzhen Government Online, reported the figure from BYD’s annual report. |
BYD’s January 1, 2025, production and sales announcement says its volume data are unaudited and may be adjusted or finally confirmed. That qualification applies to the sales-volume announcement; it should not be stretched into a claim about the status of every figure above. The reported sales total is evidence of reported volume, not an independent audit of every vehicle transaction.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
#1 Best Overall
- Official BYD Licensed Yang Wang U9 Model,Created under BYD’s official authorization, this buildable model faithfully represents the Yang Wang U9—an iconic supercar known for its futuristic design and performance-driven engineering.
- Compact 291-Piece Build for All Skill Levels, With 291 precision pieces, the set offers a fast, clean, and enjoyable building experience. Ideal for beginners, casual builders, or collectors who want a premium-looking model with an easy assembly process.
- Supercar Styling in a Display-Ready Size, Captures the streamlined shape, aggressive front design, and aerodynamic proportions of the Yang Wang U9. The finished model measures 26 × 14 × 7 cm, perfect for desks, shelves, or collections.
- Durable Structure with Smooth Rolling Wheels, Features sturdy construction, clean panel lines, and free-rolling wheels for simple hands-on interaction. A great piece for static display or light play scenarios.
- Great Gift for Car Lovers & Model Collectors，A standout collectible for fans of electric supercars, automotive design, or buildable vehicle models. Perfect for gifting to 14+and adults who appreciate officially licensed display pieces.
Which allegations remain unverified here
A News Wheel article published September 4, 2025, repeats claims attributed to a January 2025 GMT Research report, including estimates about debt and long supplier payment periods. It also repeats claims concerning “0 km used cars,” government support, recalls, and labor conditions. The article is a secondary account: it establishes that these claims have been reported, not that the underlying claims are true.
The available material does not include the original GMT Research report, the relevant regulator recall notices, primary labor-investigation documents, or primary records supporting the alleged subsidy totals. Without those records, figures or conclusions drawn from the allegations should not be presented as established facts. In particular, the evidence here does not prove hidden debt, sales inflation, a sales scheme, or imminent collapse.
Rank #2
- Model car kits built from metal body with rubber tires. Includes 190 accessories, screws, nuts, screwdrivers, wrenches, and detailed instructions
- Includes authentic 4x4 off roader details such as round headlights, raised hood, steering wheel, luggage rack, mountain tires, and full-size spare tire to be the highlight of a home or office display
- Assembly time is about 2 hours, suitable for improving children's hands-on ability and creativity, enjoy your parent-child time
- This erector set is the perfect birthday or Christmas gift for young enthusiasts who are ready to take on a challenge
- Measurements - Off-road vehicle over 3 in. (7.7 cm) high, 5.7 in. (14.5 cm) long and 3.7 in. (9.5 cm) wide
What would establish whether the claims are true
A credible assessment would test each allegation against records that can be checked independently, using consistent definitions and periods:
- Debt and supplier financing: the original GMT Research analysis and its definitions, compared with BYD’s annual-report notes on trade payables, financing, and cash.
- Government support: primary grant and subsidy records, with the categories and period clearly defined.
- Recalls: regulator notices naming affected models, defects, and remedies—not an unqualified count of recall events.
- Labor conditions and sales practices: official investigation records or other primary documentation that identifies the conduct, parties, and findings.
- Sales: evidence that distinguishes deliveries from registrations and inventory, and explains how any alleged inflation was measured.
Comparisons with other automakers would also need like-for-like measures: audited revenue and profit; cash, borrowings, and supplier payables defined consistently; sales measured on the same basis; recalls considered in light of fleet size and severity; and government support counted on a comparable basis. The cited material does not provide enough comparable evidence to rank BYD against competitors on those measures.
Rank #3
- Official BYD Licensed 1:8 Scale Collectible Faithfully replicate the Yangwang U9 supercar with this official 1:8 scale model. A highly detailed display model and a must-have for any collectible car collection.
- World's First Dancing Remote Control Car Command the world's first dancing building kit. This remote control car performs incredible moves like four-wheel independent motion and spot turns, bringing the super sports car to life.
- Authentic Engineering & STEM Details Explore advanced engineering with a W16-style engine, functional steering, gearbox, and suspension. An immersive STEM / STEAM car toy that makes a complex racing car toy model accessible.
- 3,671-Piece Building Kit for Adults A challenging 3,671-piece building block set designed for adults (16+). This TECHNIC building set offers a rewarding project with premium building blocks for adults.
- A Striking Sports Car Centerpiece Command attention with this stunning sports car display. The finished race car building kit makes a perfect display model for any home or office.
Verdict: the evidence does not support the headline
The company-reported results and Xinhua’s sales reporting do not disprove possible wrongdoing. But the allegations repeated by The News Wheel, without the underlying report or primary records, do not prove it either. On the evidence described here, calling BYD “the biggest scam in automotive history” is unsupported. A defensible conclusion would require verifiable evidence of specific deception and its scale, not growth figures on one side or unverified allegations on the other.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
