The claim is not verified by the current reliability findings available here. Consumer Reports’ current EV coverage names the Tesla Model Y its most reliable new EV in its survey summary and says Hyundai and Kia trail it. The specific Hyundai model and older ranking implied by the headline have not been identified, so it would be misleading to name a Hyundai winner.
What current Consumer Reports coverage says
Consumer Reports says the Tesla Model Y is the most reliable new EV in its current survey summary, while Hyundai and Kia fall behind. Its coverage also flags recurring reliability problems affecting the Hyundai IONIQ 5 and Kia EV6. The accessible summary does not provide an IONIQ 5 score or a complete ranked table, and it does not establish how every Hyundai EV compares with every Tesla or Toyota model. Consumer Reports’ current reliability coverage
That finding does not prove that Tesla ranks above Toyota in every reliability study. Rankings depend on the publisher, vehicles, model years, and measurement method; a claim that one Hyundai EV beat both brands needs the original ranking to be checked against those details.
Why the title’s claim needs a specific source
“Reliability ratings” can refer to different kinds of evidence. Consumer Reports uses member-reported problems to predict reliability. J.D. Power’s Vehicle Dependability Study instead counts problems reported by owners after a defined period of ownership. A score or result from one system cannot be treated as a direct ranking in the other.
#1 Best Overall
- 1 [Custom Fit for Kona 2024-2026] Laser-measured accurately to fit Hyundai Kona 2024, 2025, and 2026 models (Gas Models Only; Not for Kona Electric/EV). Features raised edges and factory retention hook compatibility to ensure a snug, non-shifting fit.
- 2.[Safe & Odorless TPE Material] Crafted from 100% non-toxic, recyclable TPE (Thermoplastic Elastomer). Latex and PVC-free, ensuring no unpleasant rubber odor even in extreme summer heat, maintaining a fresh in-car environment.
- 3.[All-Weather Extreme Protection] High-wall perimeter design traps dirt, rain, snow, mud, and liquid spills securely. Engineered to stay flexible and crack-free across harsh temperatures ranging from -40°F to 175°F.
- 4.[Anti-Slip & Enhanced Safety] Textured surface pattern channels fluids away from footwear, while the non-skid underside locks firmly with your vehicle’s floor pins, ensuring zero interference with the accelerator and brake pedals.
- 5.[Effortless Cleaning & Maintenance] Stain-resistant and waterproof surface allows quick cleanup. Simply remove the liners, hose them down with water or wipe with a damp towel, let dry, and re-install in minutes.
- Models and years: A comparison must identify the exact Hyundai, Tesla, and Toyota vehicles and model years. A brand average is not a head-to-head model result.
- Market and timing: The country and survey field dates matter because availability and results can vary by market and year.
- Metric: Predicted reliability, reported problems after three years, and an overall brand score are not interchangeable.
- Study coverage: Sample size and rules for which models qualify affect what a ranking can show.
The particular older or alternative ranking behind the headline remains unidentified. Without its publisher, date, market, comparison set, and scoring method, there is no reliable basis for saying which Hyundai EV supposedly beat Tesla and Toyota.
How the two current study results differ
Consumer Reports: predicted reliability from member surveys
Consumer Reports’ current survey coverage represents about 380,000 vehicles, spanning model years 2000 through 2025 and a few early 2026 models. Its brand ranking required data for at least two models drawn from at least two recent model years. These are U.S.-oriented member-survey findings used to predict reliability—not controlled tests of every vehicle or guarantees about an individual car. Consumer Reports’ survey and brand-ranking coverage
Rank #2
- [Product Specification] Dimension: L4.6’’ x W1.7’’ x H1.4’’; Weight: 150 g / 0.33 lb; Color: blue.
- [Material] This Hyundai Elantra toy car is made primarily from diecast metal with plastic parts and rubber tires, ensuring durability and making it a robust toy vehicle or a collectible item.
- [Interactive Functions] Equipped with a pull-back mechanism and opening doors, this 1:36 Scale Hyundai Elantra model car offers immersive and engaging fun.
- [Detailed Design] This Elantra toy car displays a detailed design that mimics the actual Elantra, complete with a rugged bumper, openable doors, realistic tires, and a detailed interior. These elements make the toy car not only fun to play with but also a great display piece.
- [Perfect for Collectors and Kids] It’s a great addition to any model car collectors or as a gift for kids (Birthday and Christmas Gifts Choice). Whether you’re a dedicated model car collector or looking for a memorable gift for a child, this Hyundai Elantra diecast model car is always a perfect choice. This small toy car is also suitable for cake decoration, as a cake topper it would be unique for your love ones.
J.D. Power: reported problems after three years
J.D. Power’s 2025 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study surveyed 34,175 original owners of 2022 model-year vehicles after three years of ownership. Fielded from August through November 2024, it covered 184 problem areas across nine categories. The overall result was 202 problems per 100 vehicles (PP100); lower PP100 indicates fewer reported problems and higher dependability. J.D. Power’s 2025 study details
| Vehicle type | 2025 U.S. VDS result |
|---|---|
| Battery-electric vehicles | 223 PP100 |
| Gas-powered vehicles | 200 PP100 |
| Hybrids | 199 PP100 |
Those are study-wide fuel-type averages, not scores for a specific Hyundai, Tesla, or Toyota. They cannot identify a winning model or confirm the headline’s comparison.
Rank #3
- [Product Specification] Dimension: L4.6’’ x W1.7’’ x H1.4’’; Weight: 150 g / 0.33 lb; Color: red.
- [Material] This Hyundai Elantra toy car is made primarily from diecast metal with plastic parts and rubber tires, ensuring durability and making it a robust toy vehicle or a collectible item.
- [Interactive Functions] Equipped with a pull-back mechanism and opening doors, this 1:36 Scale Hyundai Elantra model car offers immersive and engaging fun.
- [Detailed Design] This Elantra toy car displays a detailed design that mimics the actual Elantra, complete with a rugged bumper, openable doors, realistic tires, and a detailed interior. These elements make the toy car not only fun to play with but also a great display piece.
- [Perfect for Collectors and Kids] It’s a great addition to any model car collectors or as a gift for kids (Birthday and Christmas Gifts Choice). Whether you’re a dedicated model car collector or looking for a memorable gift for a child, this Hyundai Elantra diecast model car is always a perfect choice. This small toy car is also suitable for cake decoration, as a cake topper it would be unique for your love ones.
What this means if you are comparing EVs
Use a reliability result only for the models and years it actually covers. For a Hyundai-versus-Tesla-or-Toyota comparison, first locate the original ranking and verify its model years, market, field dates, sample, metric, and whether it ranks models or brands. Until that source is identified, the defensible conclusion is limited: current Consumer Reports coverage favors the Model Y in its new-EV survey summary, flags recurring IONIQ 5 issues, and does not establish a Hyundai EV as the reliability winner over both Tesla and Toyota.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- OFFICIAL LIVERY: Faithfully recreates the Hyundai i20 N Rally1 #11 in its 2023 Rally Croatia Power Stage Winner livery with authentic sponsor decals.
- 1:64 SCALE: Precisely crafted at 1:64 scale, capturing every detail of the championship-winning rally car in a compact, displayable size.
- COLLECTIBLE MODEL: Mini GT item #972, this diecast model is a must-have addition for WRC and rally racing enthusiasts and collectors.
- DETAILED FINISH: Features the iconic black and orange Hyundai Mobis team colors with Shell, Zagreb, and other authentic sponsor markings.
- RECOMMENDED AGE: Suitable for collectors and hobbyists ages 14 and up; ideal for display or as part of a diecast car collection.
Rank #4
- [Vehicle Fitment] Replacement for Hyundai: Ioniq (2017-2019).
- [Vehicle Fitment] Replacement for Kia: Niro (2017-2022), Niro EV (2019-2022).
- [OE Numbers] Replacement for Kia: 97133-0Z000, 97133-G2000, 97133-2E260.
- [OE Numbers] Replacement for Hyundai: 97133F2100.
- [Reference Number]: Replacement for CF12508, 93970, 232064, 042-2242, C31472, CAF10002, CAF10002P, CAF15009, CUK24004, PA10131, PC99273, RCA346, VCA-2068, VF2072, WACF0223, WCAF10002, WP2064.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
